Crimzle › Previous cases › Case 019

The Locked Preview Kidnapping

Case 019 · 20 September 2026 · Hard

Ashwick Auction Rooms had been cleared for the final evening preview before a record-setting sale. Security cameras showed the courier arriving with the pocket‑watch, signing the log, then vanishing somewhere inside the private floors. When staff forced open a locked interior door near closing time, the courier was gone, the watch case was empty, and a single typed demand waited on the nearest desk. The kidnapper wanted the auction house to suspend the sale and destroy all records of the watch’s ownership, or the courier would not be released. Four people with access to the restricted corridors remained in the building when the demand appeared, and every movement and object they handled was logged in detail.

Suspects

• Maurice Wexford

  auction house director

  Wexford oversaw the entire sale and insisted the watch remain on site overnight despite the insurer’s concerns. His calm reaction to the ransom demand struck several staff members as oddly detached.

  188 cm

• Augusta Caldicott

  provenance researcher

  Caldicott spent the day finalising catalogue notes for the high‑value lots, including the watch. She had argued strongly that the piece’s troubled ownership history should not be made public in full.

  176 cm

• Delia Yardley

  independent appraiser

  Yardley was hired for an outside valuation of the watch and several companion pieces. Her report had suggested a reserve far higher than Wexford was prepared to accept, putting her at odds with management.

  182 cm

• Elias Chetwynd

  security supervisor

  Chetwynd coordinated the guards and access keys for the preview. His logs showed no forced entry and no unauthorised exits during the crucial half hour when the courier vanished.

  168 cm

Possible tools

• the leather briefcase

  A slim, hard‑sided leather briefcase used to carry reserve documents and insurance papers between offices.

  1.2 kg

• the envelope of keys

  A heavy paper envelope holding several tagged cabinet and display keys signed out from the security desk.

  300 g

• the steel toolbox

  A compact steel toolbox carried by maintenance, stocked with basic tools suitable for working on doors, locks, and fittings.

  2.6 kg

• the document satchel

  A soft canvas satchel used to move catalogues and bidder registration forms between the administrative rooms.

  1.8 kg

Places

• the private valuation office

  A locked interior office where high‑value pieces were assessed and documented away from the public view.

  Indoors

• the reserve cataloguing room

  A back room lined with shelves of past catalogues and current sale paperwork, accessible only to staff.

  Indoors

• the security monitoring alcove

  A small recessed area by the corridor where monitors, access logs, and radio chargers were kept.

  Indoors

• the staff cloakroom

  A compact cloakroom with numbered lockers and a bench, used by staff to leave coats and personal bags.

  Indoors

Evidence & statements

1. Exactly one of these is true, never both: whoever stayed in the security monitoring alcove was the shortest of the four, or Elias Chetwynd was the one who stayed in the reserve cataloguing room.
2. Elias Chetwynd was not the one carrying the document satchel.
3. Exactly one of these is true, never both: whoever stayed in the private valuation office was the tallest of the four, or whoever stayed in the security monitoring alcove was carrying the envelope of keys.
4. If Maurice Wexford was in the private valuation office, then the object carried by whoever stayed in the private valuation office was the heaviest of all four objects.
5. At least one of these is true: Delia Yardley was carrying the envelope of keys, or Elias Chetwynd was in the private valuation office.
6. Exactly one of these is true, never both: Delia Yardley was carrying the envelope of keys, or Maurice Wexford was in the staff cloakroom.
7. At least one of these is true: whoever stayed in the staff cloakroom was carrying the document satchel, or whoever stayed in the staff cloakroom was carrying the leather briefcase.
8. A narrow smear of fresh machine oil found on the base of the steel toolbox matched residue recovered from the ransom demand: the kidnapper was the one carrying the steel toolbox.

Play this case