Crimzle › Previous cases › Case 016

The Vanishing in the Closed Courthouse

Case 016 · 15 September 2026 · Medium

The county courthouse had emptied after a long day of hearings, its corridors locked and silent. Sometime between 19:10 and 19:40, court clerk Dorothea Pemberton vanished from inside the building, leaving her access badge snapped in half on the floor and a half‑completed entry in the evidence log. All exterior doors showed no sign of forced entry, and security footage from outside revealed nobody entering or leaving. Whoever removed Dorothea did it from within, using knowledge of the courthouse routines and the sensitive evidence she was processing that evening. Four people remained inside after closing, each with a reason to fear what might be in that missing satchel.

Suspects

• Alistair Langmere

  assistant prosecutor

  A meticulous assistant prosecutor whose latest corruption case rested on exhibits logged by Dorothea. If those records showed that key evidence was mishandled, his career — and the case — could collapse overnight.

  178 cm

• Rowena Kestrel

  public defender

  A driven public defender whose client faced decades in prison if a contested surveillance drive stayed in evidence. Dorothea had hinted that she had just logged something that could change the entire case.

  168 cm

• Eugene Bellamy

  building facilities manager

  The long‑time facilities manager who knew every shortcut, master key, and blind spot in the courthouse. An internal audit Dorothea was helping with threatened to expose years of quiet overtime fraud in his department.

  185 cm

• Hugh Merrick

  county judge

  A senior judge who insisted on working late in his chambers that night. Rumours said Dorothea had been asked to quietly copy sealed files from one of his old cases, a breach that could end his tenure.

  190 cm

Possible objects

• the brass reception bell

  A solid brass bell from the front counter, heavy enough to leave a mark if swung hard, its surface smudged with recent fingerprints.

  950 g

• the leather briefcase

  A worn leather briefcase with a stiff handle and a sticking clasp, just large enough to hide case files or a small evidence pouch.

  600 g

• the steel thermos

  A tall steel thermos that still smelled of burnt coffee, its dented side suggesting it had been dropped more than once.

  750 g

• the evidence ledger

  The thick, hard‑bound ledger used to record every piece of evidence passing through the courthouse, its last page halted mid‑entry on Dorothea’s missing satchel.

  1.1 kg

Places

• the records office

  A cramped inner room lined with filing cabinets and locked shelves, where evidence ledgers and case files are stored after hours.

  Indoors

• the side corridor

  A narrow passage running behind the main courtroom, with dim emergency lights and a single security camera at one end.

  Indoors

• the judge’s chambers

  A private office with dark wood panelling, a heavy desk, and a door that locks from the inside, opening onto the quiet interior hall.

  Indoors

• the security anteroom

  A small anteroom near the staff entrance, cluttered with monitor screens, key hooks, and sign‑in logs for after‑hours access.

  Indoors

Evidence & statements

1. Exactly one of these is true, never both: whoever was carrying the evidence ledger is taller than whoever was in the judge’s chambers, or whoever was in the security anteroom was carrying the steel thermos.
2. Eugene Bellamy was the one carrying the leather briefcase.
3. Whatever was with whoever was in the judge’s chambers was heavier than whatever was with whoever was in the side corridor.
4. The leather briefcase never went into the records office.
5. Hugh Merrick spent those minutes in the side corridor.
6. A dusting of fresh paper fibres was found on the floor under a single chair, matching the torn edge of a page from the evidence ledger: the culprit was the one carrying the evidence ledger.

Play this case